%This code produces Figure 2 in the paper. ret = transpose(-0.2:0.001:0.2); %hypothetical return without guidance bias ret = [ret, NaN(size(ret,1),4)]; %stores optimal guidance bias for each return for k = 1:4 %baseline scenario lambda = 1.25; beta = 0.75; c = 2; sigma = 40; P0 = 100; if k==2; beta = 0.65;end %higher presence preference if k==3; sigma = 50; end %higher payoff uncertainty if k==4; c = 1; end %lower personal costs b1 = (1 -beta*sqrt(1+lambda))/(beta/sigma*(lambda+2*c)); b2 = (1+lambda-beta*sqrt(1+lambda))/(beta/sigma*(lambda+2*c)); for j=1:length(ret) P1unbiased = P0*(ret(j,1)+1); if P0-P1unbiased < b1 ret(j,k+1) = b1; elseif P0-P1unbiased > b2 ret(j,k+1) = b2; else ret(j,k+1) = P0-P1unbiased; end end end plot(ret(:,1)*100,ret(:,2),'linestyle','-','Color', [0.3 0.3 0.3],'LineWidth',3) hold on plot(ret(:,1)*100,ret(:,3),'linestyle','-.','Color', [0 0.5 0.5],'LineWidth',2) plot(ret(:,1)*100,ret(:,4),'linestyle',':','Color', [0.5 0 0.5],'LineWidth',2) plot(ret(:,1)*100,ret(:,5),'linestyle','--','Color', [0.5 0.5 0],'LineWidth',2) hold off set(gcf, 'Position', [100, 100, 1000, 560]) set(gca,'FontSize',14) set(gca,'fontname','times') xlabel("hypothetical stock return from $t_0$ to $t_1$ for $b=0$",'Interpreter','Latex') ylabel('optimal guidance bias $b^*$','Interpreter','Latex') xtickformat('percentage') legend('baseline scenario','lower $\beta$','higher $\sigma$','lower $c$','Interpreter','Latex','FontSize',15, 'Location','northeast','Orientation','vertical') saveas(gcf,'GuidanceModelPlot.eps','epsc') %Alternative Online Appendix model where guidance bias reduces uncertainty ret = transpose(-0.2:0.001:0.2); %hypothetical return without guidance bias ret = [ret, NaN(size(ret,1),4)]; %stores optimal guidance bias for each return for k = 1:4 %baseline scenario lambda = 1.25; beta = 0.75; c = 2; sigma = 40; P0 = 100; kappa = 1-(2*sqrt(1+lambda)-2)/lambda; if k==2; beta = 0.65;end %higher presence preference if k==3; sigma = 50; end %higher payoff uncertainty if k==4; c = 1; end %lower personal costs b1 = (1 -beta*sqrt(1+lambda))/(beta/sigma*(lambda*(1+kappa)+2*c/(1+kappa))); b2 = (1 -beta*sqrt(1+lambda))/(beta/sigma*(lambda*(1-kappa)+2*c/(1-kappa))); b3 = (1+lambda-beta*sqrt(1+lambda))/(beta/sigma*(lambda*(1+kappa)+2*c/(1+kappa))); b4 = (1+lambda-beta*sqrt(1+lambda))/(beta/sigma*(lambda*(1-kappa)+2*c/(1-kappa))); for j=1:length(ret) P1unbiased = P0*(ret(j,1)+1); if b1>=0 && P0-P1unbiased < (1+kappa)*b1 ret(j,k+1) = b1; elseif b2< 0 && P0-P1unbiased < (1-kappa)*b2 ret(j,k+1) = b2; elseif b3>=0 && P0-P1unbiased > (1+kappa)*b3 ret(j,k+1) = b3; elseif b4< 0 && P0-P1unbiased > (1-kappa)*b4 ret(j,k+1) = b4; else if P0-P1unbiased >=0 ret(j,k+1) = (P0-P1unbiased)/(1+kappa); else ret(j,k+1) = (P0-P1unbiased)/(1-kappa); end end end end plot(ret(:,1)*100,ret(:,2),'linestyle','-','Color', [0.3 0.3 0.3],'LineWidth',3) hold on plot(ret(:,1)*100,ret(:,3),'linestyle','-.','Color', [0 0.5 0.5],'LineWidth',2) plot(ret(:,1)*100,ret(:,4),'linestyle',':','Color', [0.5 0 0.5],'LineWidth',2) plot(ret(:,1)*100,ret(:,5),'linestyle','--','Color', [0.5 0.5 0],'LineWidth',2) hold off set(gcf, 'Position', [100, 100, 1000, 560]) set(gca,'FontSize',14) set(gca,'fontname','times') xlabel("hypothetical stock return from $t_0$ to $t_1$ for $b=0$",'Interpreter','Latex') ylabel('optimal guidance bias $b^*$','Interpreter','Latex') xtickformat('percentage') legend('baseline scenario','lower $\beta$','higher $\sigma$','lower $c$','Interpreter','Latex','FontSize',15, 'Location','northeast','Orientation','vertical') saveas(gcf,'GuidanceModelPlot_OA.eps','epsc')